Research:Knowledge Gaps Index/Measurement/Readers Survey 2023

From Meta, a Wikimedia project coordination wiki
Tracked in Phabricator:
Task T341890
Created
11:19, 6 September 2023 (UTC)
Duration:  2023-07 – ??-??

This page documents a research project in progress.
Information may be incomplete and change as the project progresses.
Please contact the project lead before formally citing or reusing results from this page.


This project aims to understand the demographics and motivations of Wikipedia Readers across language editions. It is part of the Knowledge Gaps Index focus on Readers of Wikipedias, and continues the work of the 2019 Readers survey.

Progress on this project can be followed at T341890.

Methods[edit]

This project uses simple random sampling of Wikipedia readers using the QuickSurveys extension. The QuickSurveys opt-in will be displayed to readers who are not logged in and will ask them whether they would like to participate in a survey to help improve Wikipedia. The survey will be conducted using LimeSurvey, an external survey tool.

The sample size goals will replicate the 2019 Readers Survey, as documented in T226273.

  • 10000 for large Wikipedias
  • 2000-5000 for medium-sized Wikipedias
  • 1500 for smaller Wikipedias

The goals of the survey are to make demographic estimates of Wikipedia readers across different language projects within the scope of the Knowledge Gaps Index, to understand motivations for reading Wikipedia, and to analyze whether there are differences by motivation and demographics in who reads which type of content.

Analyses of the survey data will primarily follow the 2019 edition of the survey.

Timeline[edit]

Month Goal
September 2023 English Wikipedia pilot
November 2023 Data collection on all wikis
December 2023 End of data collection. Data cleaning and analysis, preliminary findings
January 2024 Continued analysis
February 2024 Report published on metawiki (estimated)

Policy, Ethics and Human Subjects Research[edit]

This survey is governed by the Global Readers Survey privacy statement.

Results[edit]

Survey Administration[edit]

Surveys were fielded across 23 projects from November 14--December 18, 2023. A total of 80,242 complete survey responses were collected.

Global Readers Demographic Survey (2023) Fielding Summary
Project Fielding Dates QuickSurvey Sampling Ratio Total LimeSurvey Initiations Total Completes
arwiki (Arabic) November 28 - December 18, 2023 12.4% 40526 5186
cswiki (Czech) November 28 - December 11, 2023 10.0% 4592 1618
dewiki (German) November 28 - December 11, 2023 5.2% 23797 9589
elwiki (Greek) November 28 - December 13, 2023 20.0% 5557 1537
enwiki (English) November 14-22, 2023 2.0% 40497 9479
eswiki (Spanish) November 28 - December 18, 2023 6.6% 39071 8769
fawiki (Farsi) November 28 - December 11, 2023 2.1% 7689 1850
frwiki (French) November 28 - December 11, 2023 9.7% 23368 6617
hewiki (Hebrew) November 28 - December 13, 2023 8.6% 5044 1609
hiwiki (Hindi) November 28 - December 18, 2023 20.0% 62278 715
idwiki (Indonesian) November 28 - December 13, 2023 15.0% 13671 1516
itwiki (Italian) November 28 - December 11, 2023 2.5% 5855 1996
jawiki (Japanese November 28 - December 18, 2023 1.6% 7023 1905
kowiki (Korean) November 28 - December 18, 2023 20.0% 12800 1575
nlwiki (Dutch) November 28 - December 18, 2023 7.5% 5420 1528
plwiki (Polish) November 28 - December 11, 2023 7.5% 12341 3672
ptwiki (Portuguese) November 28 - December 18, 2023 15.0% 32457 4619
rowiki (Romanian) November 28 - December 11, 2023 21.1% 9820 2399
ruwiki (Russian) November 28 - December 18, 2023 1.5% 15637 5357
trwiki (Turkish) November 28 - December 11, 2023 7.5% 8568 1792
ukwiki (Ukrainian) November 28 - December 11, 2023 6.4% 6576 2094
viwiki (Vietnamese) November 28 - December 18, 2023 7.5% 6111 1075
zhwiki (Simplified and Traditional Chinese) November 28 - December 18, 2023 7.1% 15841 3745


Reader Motivation[edit]

Barchart showing percentage of Wikipedia readers across 22 surveyed projects who selected each listed motivation for reading the article they were sampled from (readers could select more than one motivation)

When asked what motivated them to read the article they were sampled from during the 2023 Global Readers Survey, respondents were overall most likely to say the article topic was "personally important" to them. (Respondents were able to select multiple motivations).

Faceted barchart showing percentage of readers citing each listed motivation for reading articles in each of 22 surveyed projects.

Similarly, at the project level, readers of all surveyed projects except for Korean Wikipedia were most likely to say they were reading the article because it is personally important to them. Korean Wikipedia readers were most likely to say they were "bored or randomly exploring Wikipedia for fun".


Reader Information Needs[edit]

Barchart showing Wikipedia readers' information needs

Overall, Wikipedia readers are most likely to say they are are reading to "get an overview of the topic". However, reader information needs are fairly evenly distributed with 41.2% saying they are reading for an "overview", 32.1% to "look up a specific fact or to get a quick answer", and 26.0% to "get an in-depth understanding of the topic".

Faceted barchart showing Wikipedia readers' information needs in each of 22 surveyed projects

At the project level, Farsi Wikipedia readers are most likely to say they are looking for "an in-depth understanding" (52.5%), Hebrew Wikipedia readers are most likely to say they are seeking "an overview" (50.0%), and Vietnamese Wikipedia readers are most likely to say they need to "look up a specific fact or...get a quick answer" (42.2%).


Reader Topic Prior Knowledge[edit]

Barchart showing Wikipedia readers' level of prior familiarity with the topic of the article they were reading when sampled

Overall, Wikipedia readers are more likely to say that they are already familiar with the topic they are reading about (55.0%) than not (44.2%).

Faceted bar chart showing reader topic familiarity across each of 22 surveyed projects

Readers of most language projects are similarly more likely to be reading articles on topics with which they are already familiar. However, there are some exceptions: readers of Chinese Wikipedia are particularly likely to be reading on unfamiliar topics (59.5%). In contrast, Dutch Wikipedia readers are most likely to read on familiar topics (74.6%).

Reader Age[edit]

Bar chart showing the distribution of Wikipedia readers across all sampled projects (18+ respondents only)

Of those 18 and older, respondents across all surveyed projects are most likely to be aged 18-24 (27.9% of readers 18+). However, the age distribution of readers varies considerably across the surveyed projects.

Faceted bar chart showing the age distribution of readers of 22 different Wikipedia projects (18+ readers only)

In particular, readers of Vietnamese Wikipedia are most likely to be under the age of 30 (61.5% aged 18-29), while Dutch Wikipedia (21.8% aged 18-29) and German Wikipedia (21.0% aged 18-29) readers are least likely to be under the age of 30.

Bar chart showing the share of readers aged 18-29 across 22 surveyed Wikipedia projects

Reader Gender Identity[edit]

In order to facilitate comparisons between surveys of Wikipedia readers and contributors to Wikimedia projects, this research employed a gender identity survey item aligned with that used in e.g., the [Community Insights survey].

Bar chart showing the distribution of gender identities selected by Wikipedia readers across 22 surveyed projects (responses have been recoded to mutually exclusive categories)

Across all surveyed projects, a clear majority (63.3%) of respondents identified solely as men, 25.1% identified solely as women, 6.4% identified as genderdiverse, and 5.1% declined to provide an answer.

Bar chart showing the proportion of readers who identify solely as men across 22 surveyed Wikipedia projects

Readers identifying solely as men made up an outright majority in every surveyed project, but projects like Romanian Wikipedia (54.6% readers identifying as men only) and Ukrainian Wikipedia (51.7%) are substantially closer to gender parity than projects like Turkish Wikipedia (71.7%) or Indonesian Wikipedia (70.6%).

Reader Education[edit]

This research measured education with two survey items: one asking whether respondents were currently enrolled as students and a subsequent item asking non-students to indicate their level of educational attainment.

Current students[edit]

Bar chart showing the proportion of readers who are currently enrolled as students across 22 surveyed projects

Substantial shares of readers in every surveyed project indicated that they are currently enrolled students, although this varies considerably from fewer than one-in-five overall among Dutch (19.7%) and German (19.5%) Wikipedia readers to an outright majority of Vietnamese Wikipedia readers (54.2%).

Bar chart showing the proportion of respondents aged 18-29 who are currently enrolled as students across 22 surveyed projects

In addition, current students represent a majority of younger readers (those 18-29) in each surveyed project.


Educational attainment (non-students)[edit]

Bar chart showing educational attainment for Wikipedia readers (non-students)

Overall, Wikipedia readers are highly-educated: a majority of non-students (56.0% total) have completed a Bachelors' degree (28.8%) or a post-graduate degree (27.2%).

Faceted bar chart showing the distribution of educational attainment of Wikipedia readers (non-students only) across 22 surveyed projects

At the project level, Indonesian Wikipedia readers are most likely to report an educational attainment at the upper secondary (high school) level or lower, while Polish Wikipedia readers are most likely to report holding a post-graduate degree.

Bar chart showing the proportion of readers holding a Bachelor's degree or Post-graduate degree across 22 surveyed projects (non-students only)

Among non-students, Ukrainian Wikipedia readers (76.5%) are most likely overall to report having at least a Bachelor's degree, while Indonesian Wikipedia readers are the least likely (38.1%) relative to other surveyed projects.


Reader Languages[edit]

Bar chart showing the distribution of readers by the number of languages they speak fluently

In general, Wikipedia readers are highly multilingual. When asked what languages they speak fluently, fewer than half (44%) say they are fluent in only one language, while more than one-in-five (21.5%) say they speak three or more fluently. However, readers are overwhelmingly reading in (one of) their primary languange(s).

Bar chart showing the share of readers who are reading in (one of) their primary language(s) by project

In all but one surveyed project, about nine-in-ten (or more) readers say they are reading in one of their primary languages. The relative exception to this finding is English Wikipedia, where more than one-in-four say English is not one of their primary languages.

A bar chart showing the share of readers in each of 22 surveyed projects with monolingual fluency in the project language

In contrast, the prevalence of monolinguality in the project language varies considerably by project. In general, East Asian language projects (and Greek Wikipedia) show the highest levels of monolinguality among readers—especially readers of Japanese Wikipedia (90.1%). Conversely, readers of German Wikipedia (22.3%) and Turkish Wikipedia (22.8%) were least likely to say they were monolingual in the project language.

Reader Identities[edit]

Minority Ethnicity[edit]

Bar chart showing proportion of Wikipedia readers belonging to a minority ethnic group in their country

Bar chart showing proportions of Wikipedia readers belonging to a minority ethnic group in their country in each of 22 surveyed projects


Discriminated Group Belonging[edit]

Bar chart showing proportion of Wikipedia readers who say they belong to a group discriminated against in their country

Bar chart showing proportion of Wikipedia readers who say they belong to a group discriminated against in their country in each surveyed project

Bar chart showing the reasons Wikipedia readers experience discrimination, ordered by frequency named (respondents can select more than one option)

Resources[edit]

Coming soon!

References[edit]